News
The Berlin Communiqué: A substantial document with concrete priorities for 2005
The Ministers in charge of Higher Education of almost all European states met in Berlin on 18 and 19 September 2003 to exchange views on the progress made in the Bologna Process and decide on where to go from there. Two preparatory groups had met several times since the Prague Conference in 2001 and drafted a Communiqué that was then discussed by the Ministers in Berlin.
The final version of the Berlin Communiqué contains a few very specific and important commitments. Ministers decided to give the Process further momentum, by committing themselves to three intermediate priorities for the next two years:
quality assurance,
two cycles systems and
the recognition of degrees and periods of studies.
By 2005 they expect detailed reports on the progress achieved in each country in these three areas.
As for Quality Assurance, Ministers stressed that consistent with the principle of institutional autonomy, the primary responsibility for quality assurance in higher education lies with each institution itself. They agreed that by 2005 all national quality assurance systems should include:
A definition of the responsibilities of the bodies and institutions involved.
Evaluation of programmes or institutions, including internal assessment, external review, participation of students and the publication of results.
A system of accreditation, certification or comparable procedures.
International participation, co-operation and networking.
Moreover, Ministers called upon ENQA to develop an agreed set of standards, procedures and guidelines on quality assurance and to prepare a report for the Ministers Conference in 2005.
With regard to the introduction of Bachelors/Master, Ministers they committed themselves to having started the implementation of the two cycle system by 2005.
In that context Ministers encouraged the elaboration of qualifications frameworks at national but also at European level. Such qualifications frameworks should describe qualifications in terms of workload, level, learning outcomes, competences and profile.
In the context of the recognition of degrees and periods of study, Ministers underlined the importance of the Lisbon Recognition Convention, which should be ratified by all countries participating in the Bologna Process as soon as possible. At a very concrete level, they set the objective that “every student graduating as from 2005 should receive the Diploma Supplement automatically and free of charge” and that it should be issued in a widely spoken European language.
Apart from these three intermediate priorities, Ministers considered it useful to promote closer links between the European Higher Education Area and the European Research Area in a Europe of Knowledge. They therefore went beyond the present focus on two main cycles of higher education and decided to include the doctoral level as the third cycle in the Bologna Process.
Ministers decided to adapt the clause in the Prague Communiqué on applications for membership. From now on countries party to the European Cultural Convention shall be eligible for membership of the European Higher Education Area “provided that they at the same time declare their willingness to pursue and implement the objectives of the Bologna Process in their own systems of higher education. “ Immediately afterwards Ministers accepted the requests for membership of Albania, Andorra, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Holy See, Russia, Serbia and Montenegro, and “the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”. This means that from now on the emerging European Higher Education Areas consists of 40 countries.
The overall steering of the Bologna Process and the preparation of the next ministerial meeting will be taken care of, as in the past two years, by the Bologna Follow-up Group. In Berlin it was decided that this group would from now on have one additional consultative member, i.e. UNESCO-CEPES.
A somewhat smaller Board, like the Follow-up Group to be chaired by the EU Presidency, shall oversee the work between the meetings of the Follow-up Group. Finally, the overall follow-up work will be supported by a Secretariat provided by Norway, as it will host the next Ministerial Conference: in May 2005 in Bergen.
The Berlin Communiqué contains, as the Bologna Declaration and the Prague Communiqué, references to and recommendations for all the other action lines, such as Lifelong Learning, ECTS, the attractiveness of European Higher Education etc. However, the Communiqué is not just more of what we saw in the past: By defining three priorities for 2005 and deciding on a stocktaking exercise, Ministers increased the commitment to and the speed of the process. A process that is radiating to ever more countries, as was witnessed by the various observers from Eastern Europe and Latin America present in Berlin. Now the countdown for Bergen is running and no one active in the process will find the twenty months to the next ministerial meeting too long: Governments, institutions, quality assurance bodies and everyone else will have to work hard to meet the obligations decided upon in Berlin.
14.10.2003
You can download the Communiqué here.
Trends III Report
The new Trends III Report is now available as full version and summary version.
07.10.2003
EUA Convention in Graz
On their convention in Graz (29th - 31st May 2003) the EUA had prepared a declaration which was adopted in Leuven on 4th July 2003. You can download its original wording here.
01.08.2003
Spain to reform its higher education system
On 14 February the Spanish Ministry of Education submitted to the University Council a framework document outlining the main features of the reform of higher education system in accordance with the Bologna process. The document proposes the replacement of the Spanish credit accumulation system, based on the number of class hours, with the one based on the total duration of studies, the implementation of 3+2 Bologna degree structure, the introduction of diploma supplement, and measures to strengthen quality assurance mechanisms. The report recommends gradual adoption of the new system form 2004/2005 onwards and its full implementation in all higher education institutions by 2010, the deadline stated in the Bologna Declaration. (ACA-Newsletter, No. 27)
22.07.2003
Joint declaration of the European University Networks
The Coimbra, Compostela, Santander and UNICA networks, representing 176 universities within Europe, have issued a joint declaration with regard to the Conference of European Ministers responsible for Higher Education in Berlin.
01.07.2003You can download the statement here.
New Websites
In the framework of the Bologna process, Denmark und Austria have as well set up their own website.
24.03.2003
Information on applications to join the Bologna Process
Albania, Andorra, Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Holy See, the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia as well as Serbia and Montenegro have already filed a formal application. Russia and the Ukraine have expressed their interest only informally so far.
24.03.2003
Conference on perspectives of the Bologna process for Italian and German university reforms
On the 11th and 12th March 2003, the Italian-German Foundation "Villa Vigoni" held a conference on the state of the university reforms in Italy and Germany, both initiated by the Bologna process. Participants from different sectors, such as government, university, research and industry, had the opportunity to exchange information and review progress for the creation of a European Higher Education Area in preparation for the follow-up conference of European Ministers in Berlin. The conference members underscored the importance of the following aspects for the success of the Bologna process:
· Further internationalisation of universities and intensification of mobility
· Guarantee for a wide access to university education and an increase in the quality of study offers
· Securing university autonomy as a basis of the European Higher Education Area
· Appropriate financing of university reforms.
You will find the conference programme and the summarised conference results here.
20.03.2003
Consultation process of the European Commission concerning the role of universities in the Europe of knowledge
Initiated by the Commissioners Philippe Busquin (Research) and Viviane Reding (Education and Culture), the Commission has published a communication on the role of the universities in the Europe of knowledge. The objective, formulated by the European Council in Barcelona in March 2002, to make the European systems of education a "world-class reference" by 2010, will be a great challenge for European universities. The communication seeks to start a debate on the role of universities within the knowledge society and economy in Europe and on the conditions under which they will be able to effectively play that role. The Commission invites all the interested parties to join the discussion on higher education dealing with key issues, such as funding, development of excellence, internationalisation and not least the realisation of a European Higher Education and Research Area.
11.02.2003
National Reports of the countries involved in the Bologna process
The updated versions of the National Reports concerning the realization of the goals mentioned in the Bologna Declaration are available here.
Euro Student 2000
The results of a survey concerning the Euro student 2000 have been published.
This study provides you with information on the social and economic conditions
of student life in nine EU member countries (Austria, Belgium, Finland, France,
Germany, Ireland, Italy, the Netherlands and Portugal).
Further information at:
www.his.de/Abt2/Auslandsstudium/Eurostudent/frameset.htm
18.10.2002
Commission welcomes Council's green light for EU research programmes
The Council of EU Ministers today approved the five Specific Programmes implementing the €17,5 billion 6th EU Research Framework Programme (FP6 2003-2006). "I welcome this key vote", said EU Research Commissioner Philippe Busquin. "All is now set for a rapid start to the Research Programmes with the first calls for proposals published before the end of this year. The rapid conclusion of the decision-making process on ambitious EU research programmes provides an additional strong basis for creating a true European Research Area."
Last minute discussions in Council and Parliament focused on stem cell research. The agreement reached stipulates that some detailed implementation procedures and a more comprehensive legislative act will be put in place in order to better regulate the EU funding of research involving the use of human embryonic stem cells. It foresees that, until the end of 2003, the Commission will not fund research projects involving the use of human embryonic stem cells, with the exception of stem cells already banked or isolated in culture. Next spring 2003, the Commission will publish a report on the evolution of stem cell research and organise a public seminar on the subject with Council and Parliament.
For further information please see:
http://europa.eu.int/comm/research/fp6/index_en.html
http://europa.eu.int/comm/research/fp6/documents_en.html
(EU Commission) 15.10.2002
European Research Area: National Goverments must do more
The EU Commissioner for Research, Philippe Busquin, has said that the commitment of Member States and national governments to the creation of a European research area (ERA) has so far been 'too weak or insubstantial'.
As a result, the Commission will shortly be making proposals aimed at driving the establishment of the ERA , notably, he said, 'by giving [the project] increased resources in order to fully coordinate the activities and policies of Member States.'
In a speech to the Leibniz Association, a large German research collective, on 2 October, Mr. Busquin said that his goal was to give a new impetus to the project, a key element of the Sixth Framework Programme.
The Commissioner gave a reminder that the synergy of Member States' policies was an essential element of the ERA, because the majority of European research is carried out and financed at a national level.
Reiterating the conclusions of recent benchmarking reports, Mr. Busquin also stressed the need for increased public and private investment in research, and highlighted the key role of universities as the providers of research training and sources of technological innovation.
He hopes to initiate a debate, he said, on how to provide European universities with the same level of resources as those enjoyed by the top US colleges.
(Cordis) 03.10.2002
ERASMUS WORLD
One year after adopting its Communication on reinforcing co-operation with third countries in the field of higher education (18 July 2001), the European Commission launched on 17 July 2002 a proposal for establishing a programme for the enhancement of quality in higher education and the promotion of intercultural understanding through co-operation with third countries: “ERASMUS WORLD”. From 2004-2008, the programme will be provided with a budget of 200 million euros and should promote multilateral EU Master’s degree programmes as well as university and college partnerships with third countries. Besides, the proposal includes scholarships for highly qualified students of Master’s degree programmes and guest scientists from third countries and Europe. The proposal of the Commission still needs to be adopted by the European Parliament and the Council.
20.09.2002
Towards a European Education and Research Area
An interview with Professor Hans-Rainer Friedrich, Director-General for Higher Education at the Federal Ministry of Education and Research (Germany) and in that capacity chairman of the preparatory group for the Bologna follow-up conference in Berlin.
The European Research Education Area
An interview with Nikolaus van der Pas, Director-General for Education and
Culture at the European Commission.
16.09.2002
EUA Survey on Master Degrees and Joint Degrees in Europe
With the support of the European Commission, the European University Association (EUA) published a survey informing on the state of implementation of Master degrees and the range of joint degrees in the countries of the European Higher Education Area. You can download the survey here.
20.09.2002
A Nordic Space for Higher Education
The university leaders of the Nordic countries (Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway and Sweden) passed a declaration on “A Nordic Space for Higher Education” at their conference in the Norwegian Tromsø (15-17 August 2002).
You will find the declaration in its original wording here.
12.09.2002
Flanders: New decree on the structure of higher education to be adopted autumn 2002
The Flemish Government has recently taken new steps towards a Decree on the Structure of Higher Education to be applicable form the academic year 2004-2005 on. An initial draft was approved by the Flemish Government May 24, 2002 and discussed by the Flemish Education Council (Vlaamse Onderwijsraad – VLOR) and the Social-Economic Council of Flanders (Sociaal-Economische Raad voor Vlaanderen – SERV), the two Flemish advisory bodies which are formally consulted for important legislation in the field of education. This advisory work had led to the official draft Decree which was approved by the Flemish Government on July 5, 2002 and is now subjected to the final advice of the Council of State. Final adoption of the Decree is expected for Autumn 2002.
Main objectives of the new Decree:
· Implementation of the Bologna declaration for all degrees offered in the Flemish Community of Belgium (former degree structure to die out gradually) from the academic year 2004-2005 on
· Reform of the longer academic curricula into a two-tier system, where a Bachelor Degree can be obtained after 3 years of study (180 ECTS study points) and a Master Degree after another 1 or 2 years (60 to 120 ECTS study points, with the exception of medicine which will take longer)
· Reform of the quality assurance system with integration of mechanisms for accreditation
· Closer co-operation between universities and other higher education institutions which can form so-called “associations” with each other, especially for the organisation of courses at Master’s level in the non-university higher education sector.
The draft text of the Decree (in Dutch) can be consulted on the Internet at: http://www.ond.vlaanderen.be/hoger_onderwijs/structuurdecreetstart.htm
(Ministerie van de Vlaamse Gemeenschap)22.08.2002
Quality Reform of Higher Education in Norway
In 2001 the Norwegian Parliament decided on a quality reform of higher education which will be implemented until the end of the year 2003. Primarily, the reform will improve the quality of higher education and includes the following measures:
· implementation of a new degree structure based on two or three cycles: Bachelor (3 years), Master (2 years), PhD (3 years)
· improvement of teaching through regular assessment and through a study agreement between students and universities
· application of a credit point system
· creation of a national agency for quality assurance
· implementation of an obligatory diploma supplement
· promotion of mandatory studies abroad
· financial assistance for the support of international students
· increase in scholarship awards and credit rates to finance studies
· performance-orientated financing of universities.
You will find further information at the corresponding pages of the Norwegian Ministry of Education and Research.
05.08.2002
New University Act in Austria
After being discussed in the National Council (Nationalrat) and Federal Council (Bundesrat), a new university act will become effective in Austria in October 2002. As part of a comprehensive university reform, the law should crucially strengthen the autonomy of universities. Thus far, the universities have been overseen by the Ministry of Science, but from now on they will be responsible for their own economic, personnel and strategic decisions. One condition for this is the legal autonomy and the change of the organisational structures. The ‘University Act 2002’ is integrating itself into the reform process of European universities, initiated in Bologna in 1999, and will be implemented until the beginning of the year 2004. 02.08.2002
You can download the wording of the act here.
For further information please consult the web address of the Federal Ministry for Education, Science and Culture or www.weltklasse-uni.at
02.08.2002
First European report on indicators of lifelong learning
Between seven and 32 per cent of 15 year olds in 35 European countries do not have a degree of scientific literacy necessary for productive lifelong learning in the field of science. The first European report on indicators of lifelong learning was compiled by the Working group on quality indicators of lifelong learning. The group comprises of representatives from 35 countries, the Organisation for economic cooperation and development (OECD), the United Nations educational, scientific and cultural organisation (UNESCO) and the European Commission. It examines the quality of lifelong learning in four central areas, and concludes that Europe is not performing adequately in the first of these areas:
skills, competencies and attitudes;
access and participation;
resources for lifelong learning;
strategies and systems.
The report shows that not all countries are well positioned for successful lifelong learning involving the whole population. In 2001, Greece invested 3.52 per cent of GDP in education, while Sweden invested 8.33 per cent. The EU average meanwhile amounts to 5.03 per cent. (ITB-Info-Service)
02.08.2002
Barcelona European Council supports the Bologna Process
At the conference on 15th and 16th March 2002 in Barcelona the European Council asked the member countries for closer co-operation regarding the Bologna process still before the conference in Berlin. You find the appropriate excerpts from the presidency conclusions here.
08.07.2002
Parliament approves reports on ERA
The European Parliament approved reports on strengthening and structuring the European research area (ERA) at its plenary session in Strasbourg on 12 June. In approving the report ‘Strengthening of the European research area’ prepared by MEP Wim van Velzen, Parliament highlighted specific amendments on each of the next Framework programme’s priorities.
On the report concerning the strengthening of the European research area, prepared by MEP Myrsini Zorba, Parliament highlighted five specific non-binding amendments. Firstly, inter and multidisciplinarity should be promoted through concrete actions. Secondly, synergies should be established between ERA and the proposed European higher education area. Thirdly, a mechanism needs to be established which allows DG Research to monitor and optimise research mobility. Fourthly, the programme needs to ensure that a positive attitude towards research is created among teachers and journalists. Finally, military research should be excluded from Community funding. (ITB-Info-Service)
02.07.02
‘Special push‘ needed to create Europe an higher education area by 2010
If the European Higher Education Area is to become a reality by 2010, a ‘special push’ is needed in the areas of credits for lifelong learning, European Masters and quality assurance, said EU Commissioner for Education and Culture, Viviane Reding, on 31 May. ‘We are still far away from a situation in which transparency, quality and recognition are common features in Europe,’ said Ms Reding.
Europe should become the most favoured destination for high level learning in the world, she said. Researchers from the European university association (EUA) are currently seeking to define a model for European Masters courses. They are addressing issues such as what ‘European’ is to mean in this context, what type of curriculum integration should take place, and what recognition arrangements would be implemented. The first European Masters courses could be operating in Europe as early as 2003 or 2004, said Ms Reding. (Cordis)
19.06.2002
European competitiveness is not good enough for Lisbon target-report
The Lisbon summit’s target of making Europe the most competitive knowledge-based economy by 2010 will not be met unless improvements are made in its competitive and productivity growth levels. This is one of the main conclusions of the European Commission’s 2002 competitiveness report, published on 23 May. The report focuses on the specific areas of skills and education, productivity in the services sector, sustainable development in manufacturing and the relationship between competition and enterprise policy.
Data showed that while the USA showed a rise in service sector productivity growth from 1.3 to 3.5 per cent from the first to the second half of the 1990s, most EU Member States with comparable data experienced a decline. Service productivity growth was also lower than manufacturing growth. (European Commission)
18.06.2002
A European Research Council – the Debate
Following the proposal to establish a European Research Area (ERA), formulated by Commissioner Philippe Busquin, the debate on implementation of this vision has moved on rapidly. One idea which has been suggested is that of the creation of a European Research Council (ERC), which would provide support for high-quality, long-term, curiosity-driven research.
In its Strategic Plan, 2002-2006, the European Science Foundation (ESF) has set itself the task of structuring and leading the debate on this key issue for the future of European science. To this end, it has appointed a High Level Expert Group, under the chairmanship of Sir Richard Sykes, Rector of Imperial College, London, to examine the pros and cons of the ERC concept and to produce a final report for publication early in 2003. At the same time, the incoming Danish EU Presidency (July to December 2002) has decided to promote a discussion meeting on the same topic on 7-8 October 2002. (European Science Foundation)
18.06.2002
Co-operation in science and education with Latin America and the Caribbean
The Heads of State and Government from EU, Latin America and the Caribbean signed the ‘Madrid commitment’ on 17 May, which sees a pledge to co-operate in areas of scientific, technological and educational interest. The declaration contains a commitment to co-operate on issues such as the information society, prevention and treatment for HIV/AIDS and preparedness for natural disasters. The commitment also recommends the development, approval and promotion of the 2002 to 2004 action plan for building a European Union – Latin America and Caribbean common area of higher education. (The Spanish Presidency of the Council of the EU)
18.06.2002
6th European Union research master programme settled
On June 3rd the European Council of Ministers accepted the 6th Research master programme with a total budget of 17.5 billion Euro. This scholarship programme focuses on research fields such as astronautics, biotechnology and genetic engineering concerning fight against diseases. The new master programme is implemented in order to promote the development of Europe to the most attractive research area world-wide. The European Heads of State and Government agreed already upon the creation of a common research area in Lisbon in March 2000. This is part of a comprehensive strategy, helping the European Union to become the most dynamic economic region world-wide and to neutralise the distance to the USA so far. (dpa)
04.06.2002
Towards “Lifelong Learning”
A lifelong acquisition and development of qualification and competence is not only of great importance for the personal fulfilment, but also for the future of a knowledge-based society. Therefore “lifelong learning” (LLL) is constantly on the agendas of current debates on educational policy. 1998 the Council of Europe and the Conference of the Presidents of University launched a project, which understands “lifelong learning” – including learning in the vocational sphere – as a challenge to higher education. The Bologna declaration also considers the idea of LLL, by recommending the establishment of a system of credits (such as ECTS) which enables the acquisition of credit points in non-higher education contexts. In 1999, the EU-Commission initiated a project analysing the possible development of the ECTS (European Credit Transfer System) facilitating academic recognition into a European Credit Accumulation and Transfer System (ECTS Extension Feasibility Project). Such a system would not only allow the accumulation and the transfer of credit points from university to university but also from the sphere of vocational training to higher education institutions. Various countries participating in the Bologna Process have already taken concrete measures to implement the academic recognition of “lifelong learning”. Germany explores currently in the field of vocational training of IT professionals whether credits acquired in work based mode can be recognised within the framework of university degrees such as Bachelor and Master.
04.06.2002
Current information on doctoral studies in Europe
The last meeting of the Directors-General of higher education took place in Cordoba from 7th to 9th April with participation of the Presidents of the Rectors‘ Conferences of the EU/EEA states. The participants discussed the topic “High Quality Doctorates: Engine of Knowledge, Development and Innovation in Europe”. Two workshops dealt with the quality of doctoral studies and the mobility of doctoral candidates. In Cordoba DFG (The German Research Association) presented the state of doctoral studies in Germany.
In the last year’s meeting in Halmstad (6-8 May 2001) a study (“Doctoral Student Mobility in the Framework of the Socrates/Erasmus Programme 1995-2000”) initiated by the EU Commission supplied essential facts concerning doctoral students’ mobility in 29 European countries.
An updated study, that includes the academic year 2000/2001, has been discussed in Cordoba comparing doctoral mobility of the Marie-Curie Research and ERASMUS programmes for 2000/2001.
29.05.02
EURASHE policy statement on the Bologna-Prague-Berlin process
Here you find a discussion document covering a number of key elements in the Bologna Declaration which are of particular importance to the sector represendet by EURASHE. 23.05.2002
Statement of the Federal Ministry of Education and Research concerning the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS)
The German Federal Ministry of Education and Research addressed a statement to the Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology concerning the contribution towards EU coordination with regard to the forthcoming negotiations on educational services.
22.05.2002
Results of the Stockholm, Lisbon and Amsterdam conferences are now available.
Several seminars take place on the way to the Bologna follow-up meeting in Berlin.
If you do need further information please click here.
Annual Meeting of the Network of Central and Eastern European Quality Assurance Agencies in Higher Education and ENQA Workshop
According to the decision of the Krakow annual meeting of the CEE Network last year, the Czech Accreditation Commission prepares the annual meeting of the Network and ENQA Workshop in Prague in October 18-19,2002. The results will be available soon after the conference.
08.05.2002
ESIB-newsletter (PDF-Data) April 2002 just published.
This issue of the Bologna Process Committee (BPC) Newsletter, published by ESIB, the National Unions of Students in Europe, will give you an overview on several seminars and meetings attended by the members of the BPC, a country report about the higher education reform in Norway and special focus to the transperancy in higher education.
Closing Conference of the Pilot Project "Tuning Educational Structures in Europe"
The Tuning project is a university initiative coordinated by the universities of Deusto (Spain) and Groningen (The Netherlands). Over one hundred universities are participating in the project.
The Socrates supported Tuning project addresses several of the objectives of the Bologna process, notably the establishment of readable and comparable degrees and the adoption of a two cycle system, whilst maintaining university autonomy and diversity.
More specifically, the project aims at identifying generic and subject specific competences for first and second cycle studies in seven subject areas (Business studies, Education Sciences, Geology, History, Mathematics, Chemistry and Physics) and provides a methodology for analysing common elements and differences.
More information on Tuning you will find on the project website:http://odur.let.rug.nl/TuningProject/index.htm
Bachelor's/Master's degree structure to be introduced in 2002 - Dutch Cabinet approves „bachelor-master“ bill
The Dutch Cabinet approved the bill submitted by the Minister of Education, Culture and Science, Lock Hermans, for the introduction of the Bachelor's/Master's degree structure in higher education in the Netherlands. The proposed legislation will allow Dutch universities and institutes of higher professional education to switch to the new system as of the 2002 academic year. Expectations are that the majority of university programmes will in fact make the switch immediately.
Universities will also be allowed to subject students to a selection process for special Master's programmes. For these programmes, which will have extra facilities and will be of a higher standard, universities will be permitted to charge up to five times the statutory tuition fee.If a student is unable to pay, the university will be obliged to look for ways for the student to finance his or her studies so that he or she can in fact enter the programme.
In order to help finance the introduction of the new Bachelor's/Master’s degree structure, Dutch universities will receive a one-off grant of NLG 100 m (NLG 50m in 2001 and NLG 50m in 2002). These funds are provided for in the government’s interim budget report.
(ITB-Info-Service, 12. November 2001)
New University Degree in France
With the beginning of the academic year 2002/2003 a new university degree will be implemented – the ”Master”. The new degree which corresponds to the German ”Magister” will be awarded after five years of study. The French government in Paris had decided on the reform two years ago in order to contribute to the convergence of the European university systems.
(dpa Paris)